A Landlord Has A Duty To Protect Tenants From The Foreseeable Criminal Acts Of Third Parties

By Jonathan R.  Mehl, Esq.

The question at times arises as to when a Landlord’s faces a responsibility for the criminal acts of third parties. This issue was again ruled on by the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey in the tragic circumstances in the case of Pitts v. Gianini v. Brady, decided on December 4, 2019.

A five year old girl and her mother were murdered in a four family house owned by Gianini. Brady was the ex-boyfriend of the mother. There were two entrances to the main lobby from which there was access to the two units on the first floor, and to the stairway for the two units on the second floor. The decedents lived on the first floor. The lawsuit was brought by Pitts, who was the administrator of the estate.

When Pitts was unable to reach the decedent, she went to the property. The front door was unlocked as was the window to the apartment. Plaintiff brought the lawsuit alleging that Gianini negligently operated and maintained the property.

The Appellate Division began its analysis recognizing the elements of any negligence claim: duty of care, breach of duty, injury proximately related to the breach of duty, and resulting damages. These standards apply in any negligence case.

Even in a landlord – tenant relationship setting, Courts have held that “Negligence is tested by whether the reasonably prudent person at the time and place should recognize and foresee an unreasonable risk or likelihood of harm or danger to others.” (quoting Trentacost v. Brussel, 82 N.J., 214, 222 (1980).

There is a “modern view” held by the courts that “landlords have a duty to protect patrons and tenants from foreseeable criminal acts of third parties occurring on their premises.” Clohesy v. Food Circus Supermarkets, 149 N.J. 496, 504 (1997). Hence, “[a] landlord has a duty to exercise reasonable care to guard against foreseeable dangers arising from use of those portions of the rental property over which the landlord retains control.” J.H. v. R&M Tagliareni, LLC, 239 N.J. 198, 218 (2019).

This begs the question as to what is foreseeable? The answer is that foreseeability “refers to… `the risk reasonably within the range of apprehension, of injury to another person, that is taken into account in determining the existence of the duty to exercise care.’ Clohesy, 149 N.J. at 502-03. The court will also consider fairness and public policy, and assess the totality of the circumstances. Thus, if for example there were prior criminal activities in the area, this can be considered.

When going through the history of the law, the Appellate Division referred to a prior case where the landlord did not provide adequate locks and there was a robbery a week after a tenant’s complaint, and there was a history of frequent break-ins in the area. Braitman v. Overlook Terrace Corp., 68 N.J. 368 (1975).

Ultimately, the Court in Pitts found that the “plaintiff was not required to present evidence that the same or similar offenses had been committed on the property or in close proximity to the building where” the murders occurred. It was sufficient to bring the case to trial for the Plaintiff to have shown that the entrance door lock was broken, and that the tenant had complaint to the landlord about it. Thus, “it was reasonably foreseeable that an intruder could enter defendants’ building through the unlocked front door and, once in the entrance hallway, force his or her way into an apartment.”

Because the landlord knew of the broken lock, and had the ability to repair it, this played into the totality of circumstances analysis. Also, as a matter of public policy the Court ruled that landlords must comply with regulations pertaining to repairs. Accordingly, a ruling was made that the landlord owed a duty of care to the tenant.

The bottom line is that if there are safety issues in your building, these should be promptly and properly addressed. As it pertains to criminal acts of third parties, a court may very well determine that if the property is located in a high crime area, that there is a greater foreseeability of criminal acts by third parties that could affect tenants. Therefore, if you as a landlord are aware of any safety issues, or other issues that could result in injury to a tenant or others visiting your property, you are best to promptly attend to the items.

Jonathan R.  Mehl, Esq. is recognized in the community as an ethical and highly skilled attorney, who is dedicated in effectively getting to the bottom line in achieving the client’s goals. Jonathan R. Mehl graduated Seton Hall University School of Law, Newark, New Jersey, in 1991. He earned his undergraduate degree from The George Washington University, Washington, D.C., in 1987. Jonathan R. Mehl is admitted to practice law in New Jersey, New York, and the District of Columbia. He has served on a New Jersey District Legal Ethics Committee, and the New Jersey Supreme Court Rules Committee for the Special Civil Part.Since 1996 Jonathan R. Mehl, P.C. has maintained the law firm in Rutherford, New Jersey. He can be reached at (201) 804-0040 or via email at Jonathan@mehllegal.com

Read more information on this topic.

Small Landlord Emergency Grant Program (SLEG) Announced

Small Landlord Emergency Grant Program (SLEG) AnnouncedDuring a press conference earlier today, Governor Murphy announced the Small Landlord Emergency Grant Program (SLEG) to assist small rental property owners (3-10 unit properties) and their tenants during the...

FRKB& G Presents Supreme Court Issues Order Lifting Indefinite Suspension of Landlord/Tenant Trials in Very Limited Circumstances

FRKB&G Supreme Court Issues Order Lifting Indefinite Suspension of L/T Trials in Very Limited CircumstancesSince Governor Murphy declared a State of Emergency and a Public Health Emergency, Courts hearing landlord/tenant cases came to a halt. Courthouses were...

What Residential Landlords and Tenants Should Know About Breaking a Lease during the Covid-19 Pandemic

What Residential Landlords and Tenants Should Know About Breaking a Lease during the Covid-19 PandemicBy Josean Otero, Esq. Many tenants are facing immense emotional and financial pressure as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and are considering breaking their lease....

COVID-19 Short-Term Rental Assistance Program (CVERAP)

COVID-19 Short-Term Rental Assistance Program (CVERAP)As a part of the Murphy Administration’s response to assist New Jersey residents affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, Governor Murphy and Lieutenant Governor Oliver announced the COVID-19 Short-Term Rental Assistance...

Renters May Now Use Security Deposit For Rent Payments

Renters May Now Use Security Deposit For Rent PaymentsOn Friday, April 24th Governor Murphy signed Executive Order -128 allowing renters to utilize their security deposits for rental payments. For a copy of this order

Rent Freezing in North Jersey and Beyond

Rent Freezing in North Jersey and BeyondWe hope you are all managing and staying healthy throughout these difficult times. Governments across the country are taking action to help keep tenants in their homes and stop evictions. For example, evictions are not happening...

FRKB & G Presents “The Obligation to Pay Rent and the Courts: The Latest”

FRKB & G Presents “The Obligation to Pay Rent and the Courts: The Latest”Like you, we're closely monitoring the quickly developing effects of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. We have received several calls from members concerned about the effects of the...

NMHC Presents “Tools for Communicating with Residents Regarding Rent Flexibility, Federal Assistance and Rent Obligations” covid, News & Views

NMHC Presents “Tools for Communicating with Residents Regarding Rent Flexibility, Federal Assistance and Rent Obligations”Like you, we're closely monitoring the quickly developing effects of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. We have received several calls from...

Brach Eichler Presents “How to Protect Your Multifamily Apartment Business by Seeking Relief Under COVID-19-Related Laws”

Brach Eichler Presents “How to Protect Your Multifamily Apartment Business by Seeking Relief Under COVID-19-Related Laws”Please see this latest contribution from POA member Brach Eichler on the current situation for owners hereRead More About COVID-19Read More News...

COVID-19 & SBA Economic Disaster Loan Information

COVID-19 & SBA Economic Disaster Loan InformationLike you, we're closely monitoring the quickly developing effects of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. We have received several calls from members concerned about the effects of the moratorium on evictions. We...

Peruse other News & Views Posts.